Toilet Failure Case Study: A Single-Line Chain of Custody

When a policyholder filed a claim citing unexplained fractures in their toilet, the adjuster managing the claim faced critical questions. What caused the fractures? Could a third party be responsible for the loss?
To find answers and assess subrogation potential, the adjuster decided to pursue product failure testing. But another challenge emerged: how to transport the toilet without risking additional damage.
The adjuster chose Component Testing Laboratories (CTL) for their Professional Engineers and evidence handling expertise supported by its in-house service, Loss Logistics.
Complete the form to receive the case study and discover how CTL:
- Safely transported the evidence through Loss Logistics
- Preserved a single-line chain of custody with thorough documentation
- Conducted non-destructive testing to determine the root cause of the toilet failure
- Researched manufacturer trends and reports
- Provided a detailed and actionable report to inform subrogation decisions
Don’t miss insurance-focused resources and webinars about property, perils, and trends impacting claims nationwide by signing up for The Savvy Adjuster Newsletter.
Be sure to also tune in to The Savvy Adjuster Podcast to hear more from the experts themselves.
Alpine Intel’s content is meant to inform and educate readers using general terms and descriptions. They do not replace expert evaluations that determine facts and details related to each unique claim.
Get Your Copy
Related Resources
Valve Failure Case Study
The Component Testing Laboratory team determined that a leaking washing machine valve was caused by a manufacturer’s defect. Read about the process in this case study.
Sump Pump Failure Case Study
Learn how CTL’s Professional Engineer used non-destructive testing to uncover the cause of a sump pump failure so that an adjuster could evaluate subrogation potential.
Computer Electrical Failure Claim Case Study
Learn how one adjuster got the answers they needed about a reported electrical fire from National Fire Experts, even after the scene had been altered.



